“Best Cost Country” (BCC) sourcing is a strategy a category manager can chose, focused on identifying and utilizing countries that offer the optimal mix of cost-efficiency, quality, and innovation for procuring specific goods and services. Unlike traditional low-cost country sourcing, which primarily targets countries with the lowest production costs, BCC sourcing considers a broader set of factors, including the total cost of ownership, logistical efficiencies, political stability, currency exchange rates, and environmental regulations.

Explanation and Illustration

Best Cost Country sourcing requires a comprehensive assessment of various countries’ capabilities and costs associated with manufacturing and service provision. For instance:

• Labor Costs: Countries like Vietnam and Bangladesh may offer lower labor costs compared to China, making them attractive for manufacturing labor-intensive products like garments and footwear.
• Material Costs: Regions rich in natural resources, such as South America for soybeans and copper, can offer competitive pricing for these raw materials due to lower extraction and transportation costs.
• Quality and Innovation: Countries like Germany and Japan are recognized for their high-quality manufacturing standards and innovative capabilities, particularly in automotive and electronics industries, despite higher labor costs.
• Logistics and Tariffs: Proximity to key markets can reduce transportation costs and lead times. For instance, Mexico has become a favored manufacturing location for companies serving the North American market, benefiting from lower tariffs and transportation costs under agreements like the USMCA.

Impact of CO2

Carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions is becoming an increasingly important factor in global sourcing decisions, as governments impose carbon taxes and cap-and-trade systems to combat climate change and companies commit to reduce their CO” footprint. These effects can significantly alter the total cost of ownership by increasing operational expenses for manufacturers and, consequently, the cost of products.

For example, a company sourcing from a country with high level of CO2 emission in electricity generation (example) might find that the cost advantages gained from lower labor or material costs are offset by the effects associated with CO2 emissions. This is particularly relevant for industries with high carbon footprints, such as steel, cement, and energy-intensive manufacturing.

Consider the following scenarios:

• Manufacturing in a High Carbon “Cost” Region: A category manager sourcing steel from a country with stringent carbon emmision might find the final cost of the steel higher than anticipated due to the added CO2 costs, despite favorable raw material costs.
• Shift to Renewable Energy Sources: A supplier in a country investing in renewable energy sources might offer more competitive pricing over time as the cost associated with CO2 emissions decreases, enhancing their attractiveness as a BCC option.

Reflection

Understanding the dynamics of “Best Cost Country” sourcing is critical for category managers in today’s globalized economy. It requires a nuanced approach that balances cost, quality, and sustainability considerations. The inclusion of CO2 costs in the total cost assessment reflects the evolving nature of global trade, where environmental sustainability is becoming as crucial as economic efficiency. As such, category managers must stay informed about global trends, including environmental regulations and carbon pricing, to make strategic sourcing decisions that align with both cost objectives and corporate sustainability goals.

A professional buyer making Best Cost Country (BCC) sourcing decisions requires comprehensive input data to ensure an optimal balance of cost, quality, risk, and sustainability. Gathering this data involves a multi-faceted approach, leveraging various sources and tools to build a holistic view of potential sourcing destinations.

Here are several key strategies and sources for obtaining the necessary input data:

1. Market Research and Industry Reports

• Sources: Reputable market research firms (e.g., McKinsey & Company, Boston Consulting Group, Frost & Sullivan) and industry-specific publications.
• Purpose: To gain insights into industry trends, labor market conditions, supply chain dynamics, and regulatory environments in potential sourcing countries.

2. Supplier Assessment Platforms

• Sources: Platforms like EcoVadis, Achilles, and Sedex provide assessments on suppliers’ sustainability, ethical practices, and risk profiles.
• Purpose: To evaluate potential suppliers’ capabilities, sustainability practices, and risk factors, ensuring alignment with the buyer’s corporate values and risk management policies.

3. Trade Data and Tariff Information

• Sources: Government trade portals, World Trade Organization (WTO), and customs databases offer detailed data on tariffs, trade agreements, and customs procedures.
• Purpose: To understand the implications of tariffs, trade barriers, and free trade agreements on total landed cost and sourcing strategy.

4. Economic and Political Stability Indicators

• Sources: Financial institutions and international organizations (e.g., World Bank, International Monetary Fund) provide reports and databases on economic indicators, political stability, and risk ratings.
• Purpose: To assess the economic and political environment of potential sourcing countries, focusing on factors that may impact supply chain stability and operational risks.

5. Cost of Doing Business

• Sources: Consultancies specializing in cost of doing business analyses, such as KPMG and Deloitte, offer insights into labor costs, taxation, energy costs, and other operational expenses.
• Purpose: To compare the cost structures across different countries, considering factors like labor costs, utilities, taxes, and logistics.

6. Logistics and Infrastructure Quality

• Sources: Logistics performance indexes (e.g., World Bank’s LPI) and infrastructure rankings provide insights into the quality of logistics and transportation infrastructure.
• Purpose: To evaluate the efficiency of logistics and the quality of infrastructure, which can significantly affect delivery times and logistics costs.

7. Environmental and Sustainability Regulations

• Sources: Environmental agencies, sustainability organizations, and regulatory bodies offer information on environmental standards and regulations.
• Purpose: To understand environmental regulations, carbon pricing mechanisms, and sustainability standards that could impact sourcing decisions and operational costs.

8. Technology and Innovation Ecosystem

• Sources: Technology and innovation reports, patent databases, and academic research.
• Purpose: To assess the level of innovation, technology development capabilities, and intellectual property environment in potential sourcing countries.

9. Local Expertise and Networks

• Sources: Local chambers of commerce, industry associations, and consultancy firms with local presence.
• Purpose: To leverage local knowledge and networks for insights into market conditions, supplier capabilities, and potential business partners.

Summary Best Cost Country explained to buyers

Gathering input data for Best cost Country sourcing decisions is a complex and multifaceted task that requires leveraging a wide range of sources and tools. By systematically assessing information from these varied sources, professional buyers can make informed decisions that balance cost efficiencies with quality, risk, and sustainability considerations, ultimately optimizing their global sourcing strategies.

Learn more about sourcing in the bundle of courses called The sourcing engine room – a modern sourcing process. The Sourcing Engine room is build around three courses presenting the basics of a modern sourcing process. Learn about the key activities when preparing, negotiating and implementing a new improved supply chain.

Illustration to the blogpost “Best Cost Country explained” is created by Chat GPT on March 27, 2024.

If you want to learn more in Swedish about LHTS’ courses, visit Utbildning Inköp.