Hedging a purchase order can be a useful tool

Hedging a purchase order can be a useful tool for companies to manage their financial risks. Essentially, hedging involves taking an offsetting position to protect against potential losses from price fluctuations in the underlying asset. In the case of a purchase order, this would typically involve hedging against currency or commodity price risks.

What is hedging of currency exchange rate?

Hedging of a currency exchange rate involves taking an offsetting position in the foreign exchange market in order to protect against potential losses from currency exchange rate fluctuations.

For example, imagine a company in the United States that needs to pay a supplier in Europe for goods they purchased. If the exchange rate between the U.S. dollar and the Euro changes before the payment is made, the company may end up paying more or less for the goods than they had anticipated. This uncertainty can create risk for the company.

To hedge against this risk, the company can take an offsetting position in the foreign exchange market. This might involve purchasing a forward contract or a currency option that allows the company to lock in a specific exchange rate for a specific time period. By doing so, the company can protect against the risk of the exchange rate moving against them and potentially increasing the cost of the goods they need to purchase.

While hedging a currency exchange rate can protect against potential losses, it can also limit potential gains if the exchange rate moves in a favorable direction. As with any financial strategy, it is important to carefully consider the risks and benefits before implementing a hedging strategy.

The purpose of hedging a purchase order is to reduce uncertainty and protect against potential losses. For example, if a company is purchasing goods from a supplier in a foreign currency, they may be exposed to currency fluctuations that could increase the cost of the goods. By hedging their purchase order, the company can lock in a favorable exchange rate and protect against the risk of the currency moving against them.

The working procedures for hedging a purchase order typically involve a few key steps:

Identify the risk: The first step is to identify the potential risks associated with the purchase order. This may include currency risks, commodity price risks, or other factors that could impact the cost of the goods.
Determine the appropriate hedge: Once the risks have been identified, the company will need to determine the appropriate hedge to use. This may involve purchasing options or futures contracts, or using other financial instruments to offset the risk.
Execute the hedge: Once the appropriate hedge has been identified, the company can execute the hedge by purchasing the necessary financial instruments.
Monitor and adjust the hedge: Finally, the company will need to monitor the performance of the hedge and adjust it as necessary to ensure that it continues to provide adequate protection against the identified risks.

Case: Hedging a Purchase order

Let’s consider a scenario where a professional buyer is placing a Purchase Order (PO) with a supplier in a different country. The payment for this PO will be made in the supplier’s currency, which is different from the buyer’s local currency. This situation presents a currency risk due to potential fluctuations in the exchange rate over time. To manage this risk, the buyer can use a hedging strategy. Here’s an illustrative example:

Scenario

Buyer’s Local Currency: USD (U.S. Dollars)
Supplier’s Currency: EUR (Euros)
PO Amount: €100,000
Current Exchange Rate: 1 EUR = 1.10 USD
Payment Due: In 6 months
Objective: Hedge against the risk of EUR appreciating against USD
Hedging Strategy: Forward Contract

A forward contract is an agreement to buy or sell a currency at a predetermined exchange rate at a specified time in the future.

Steps

Current Situation:

The buyer needs €100,000 in 6 months.
The current exchange rate is 1.10, so €100,000 would cost $110,000 today (€100,000 * 1.10).
Setting Up the Forward Contract:
The buyer enters into a forward contract with a bank to buy €100,000 in 6 months.
Let’s assume the forward exchange rate for 6 months is 1.12 (this rate includes a premium for the time period).

Outcome in 6 Months

Scenario A: If the EUR appreciates to 1.15, without hedging, the buyer would pay $115,000 (€100,000 * 1.15).
Scenario B: With hedging, the buyer still pays at the rate of 1.12, costing $112,000 (€100,000 * 1.12).

Calculation

Cost without Hedging: €100,000 * 1.15 = $115,000
Cost with Hedging: €100,000 * 1.12 = $112,000

Hedging Benefit

Savings: $115,000 (Cost without Hedging) – $112,000 (Cost with Hedging) = $3,000
The buyer saved $3,000 by hedging against the currency risk.

Conclusion case

In this case, by entering into a forward contract, the buyer locked in an exchange rate for the future payment. When the EUR appreciated against the USD, the buyer was protected against the increase in cost, leading to a saving of $3,000. This is a classic example of how hedging can be effectively used to mitigate currency risk in international transactions.

Financial Instruments to Hedge Future Currency Purchases

Several financial tools can help lock in a currency rate or protect against unfavorable movements. Here’s a breakdown of the most common ones:

1. Forward Contracts

What it is: A forward contract is an agreement between two parties to exchange currency at a fixed exchange rate on a specific future date.
How it works: Let’s say you need to pay a supplier in euros (€) three months from now. You can use a forward contract to lock in the current exchange rate, so even if the euro strengthens against your currency in the next three months, you’ll still pay the agreed rate.
Benefits: You eliminate uncertainty because you know exactly what the exchange rate will be when the payment is due.

2. Currency Options

What it is: A currency option gives you the right, but not the obligation, to exchange currency at a specified rate by a certain date.
How it works: With options, you pay a premium upfront. If the market moves in your favor, you can let the option expire and take advantage of the better rate. If the market moves against you, you exercise the option to get the agreed-upon rate.
Benefits: You gain flexibility because you can choose to use the option if the rate works in your favor or ignore it if a better rate becomes available. However, you have to pay for this flexibility through the premium.

3. Currency Swaps

What it is: A currency swap is a financial contract where two parties exchange a set amount of currency now and then reverse the exchange at a specified date in the future, usually at an agreed rate.
How it works: For example, if you need euros for a future transaction, you can swap your currency for euros today, use those euros as needed, and then reverse the swap later when the payment is due.
Benefits: This can help manage both interest rate and currency risk, making it useful for companies with ongoing international transactions.

4. Money Market Hedge

What it is: This involves using the money markets (where short-term borrowing and lending occur) to create a hedge for currency exposure.
How it works: If you need to make a payment in a foreign currency in the future, you borrow that foreign currency now, exchange it for your home currency, and invest the money until you need to make the payment. The loan is repaid at the future exchange rate.
Benefits: This can be complex but helps lock in the current exchange rate while also potentially earning interest on the home currency.

5. Natural Hedge

What it is: A natural hedge is a strategy where companies match foreign currency inflows (sales or revenues) with outflows (purchases or expenses) in the same currency.
How it works: For instance, if you generate revenue in euros, you can use those euros to pay for purchases, reducing your exposure to currency fluctuations.
Benefits: This method doesn’t involve financial contracts, making it a simple and cost-effective way to reduce risk.

Role Typically Handling Hedges: Treasury or Risk Management Specialist

The responsibility of handling hedging strategies generally falls under the Treasury Department or a Risk Management Specialist. These professionals focus on managing the company’s financial risks, including currency risk, and ensuring that the company’s cash flows and financial health are stable. Hence there is a dialogue between this role and the Operative buyer when it comes to hedging a purchase order.

Job Description: Treasury/Risk Management Specialist

Treasury department responsible for hedging future purchases in foreign currencies

Role Overview: The Treasury or Risk Management Specialist manages the company’s exposure to financial risks, including foreign exchange (FX) risk, interest rates, and commodity prices. In terms of currency hedging, they design, execute, and monitor hedging strategies to protect the company from adverse currency movements.
Key Responsibilities:
- Evaluate Currency Risk: Analyze and assess the company’s exposure to foreign exchange rate fluctuations.
- Develop Hedging Strategies: Recommend and implement hedging strategies using tools like forward contracts, options, and swaps to mitigate risk.
- Execute Hedging Contracts: Engage with banks or financial institutions to execute forward contracts, options, or other financial instruments.
- Monitor and Report: Continuously monitor hedging positions and report on the effectiveness of these strategies to management.
- Collaborate: Work closely with the procurement and finance teams to align on purchasing needs and cash flow management.
- Stay Informed: Keep up with market trends, economic news, and financial products that can impact hedging strategies.
Skills Required:
- Strong knowledge of financial markets and instruments.
- Analytical skills to assess risk and make informed decisions.
- Attention to detail to ensure accuracy in executing financial contracts.
- Good communication skills to explain strategies and risks to other departments.

Key Components of a Hedging Policy for Purchase Orders

In many organizations, a policy or set of rules is established to determine which purchase orders (POs) should be hedged and when the operative buyer should notify the treasury department to implement the hedging strategy. These rules help streamline communication between the procurement and treasury teams, ensuring timely and appropriate risk management. Let’s break down the common components of such policies:

1. Threshold for Hedging

Policy: Many companies set a monetary threshold to decide which POs should be hedged. Only purchases above a certain value are considered significant enough to hedge.
Example: “Any PO with a value exceeding $100,000 in a foreign currency must be reviewed for potential hedging.”
Rationale: Hedging incurs costs, such as fees or premiums for instruments like forward contracts or options. For smaller transactions, these costs might outweigh the benefits of the hedge.

2. Currency Exposure

Policy: The policy may specify which foreign currencies are high-risk and should always be considered for hedging. This is often based on historical volatility or economic conditions in the countries where purchases are made.
Example: “Any purchase in volatile currencies like the Argentine peso (ARS) or Turkish lira (TRY) must be hedged, regardless of the PO value.”
Rationale: Certain currencies are prone to large fluctuations, making it essential to hedge even smaller amounts in these cases.

3. Timing of Hedging (Lead Time)

Policy: The hedging policy usually defines a specific timeframe when the treasury should be notified, allowing enough time to execute the hedge before the purchase payment is due.
Example: “Operative buyers must notify the treasury at least 30 days prior to the due date of the PO to evaluate and initiate a hedging strategy.”
Rationale: This ensures the treasury team has enough time to assess the market, execute the hedge at favorable rates, and complete all necessary documentation.

4. Hedge Instrument Selection Criteria

Policy: The policy might outline which financial instruments are preferred for hedging, such as forward contracts, options, or currency swaps, depending on the company’s risk tolerance.
Example: “For transactions under $1M, forward contracts will be the preferred instrument, while for larger purchases, the treasury may consider options to provide more flexibility.”
Rationale: Different hedging instruments provide various levels of protection and flexibility, and the policy helps ensure consistency in how financial instruments are used.

5. Operative Buyer’s Role

Policy: The operative buyer is often responsible for monitoring upcoming foreign currency payments and notifying the treasury department based on established triggers.
Example: “When issuing a PO in a foreign currency, the buyer must check if the value exceeds the hedging threshold and inform treasury within 48 hours.”
Rationale: This ensures that currency risk is flagged early and that treasury has time to consider hedging options.

6. Treasury’s Role

Policy: The treasury team is responsible for evaluating the company’s overall exposure to foreign currency risk, determining the best hedging strategy, and executing the necessary transactions.
Example: “Upon notification, treasury will assess the PO and market conditions and decide whether to use a forward contract, currency options, or another suitable instrument.”
Rationale: Treasury has the expertise and tools needed to make decisions about financial risk management.

7. Periodic Review of Hedging Effectiveness

Policy: The policy may include a requirement for regular reviews to assess whether the current hedging strategy is effective and aligned with the company’s risk tolerance.
Example: “Treasury will review hedging outcomes on a quarterly basis to ensure that the strategies used are effective in mitigating currency risks.”
Rationale: This ensures that the company is using the most efficient and cost-effective strategies and adjusting based on market conditions.

Conclusion – Hedging a purchase order

Overall, hedging a purchase order can be a useful way for companies to manage their financial risks and protect against potential losses. By following the appropriate working procedures, companies can effectively hedge against currency and commodity price risks and reduce uncertainty in their supply chain.

Hedging is an essential tool in managing the risks associated with purchasing goods in foreign currencies. By using instruments like forward contracts, options, and swaps, companies can protect themselves from currency fluctuations that could impact their profitability. The Treasury Department or Risk Management Specialist plays a key role in implementing these strategies to ensure the company’s financial stability and minimize risk in the procurement process.

A clear policy around which POs to hedge and when the treasury should be notified ensures that currency risk is managed effectively. The operative buyer’s role is critical in flagging high-risk transactions, while the treasury team brings the expertise needed to execute the right financial strategies. By working together, both teams help protect the company from unexpected cost increases due to currency fluctuations.

Learn about the Sourcing process which should include decision regarding Hedging of a Purchase Order.

The sourcing engine room is build on three courses presenting the basics of a modern sourcing process. Learn about the key activities when preparing, negotiating and implementing a new improved supply chain.

About Learn How to Source

Learn How to Source is an online platform based in Sweden, offering a range of procurement courses accessible globally. It serves as a community where procurement experts share their knowledge through online courses, designed for various experience levels from introductory to expert. Courses are concise, about 30 minutes each, and cover different aspects of procurement, tailored for different buyer roles. The courses focus on practical knowledge, presented by seasoned professionals, and include quizzes and certificates. They can be accessed from any device, emphasizing microlearning for flexibility and efficiency. More about LHTS in Swedish.

Note: Illustration to the blogpost “Enriching procurement data – example and sources” was created by ChatGPT on September 15, 2024.

Tags: Basic level hedging